Bosch Garden Shredders -tested, explained by Fred-in-The Shed

buying advice and maintenance  tips

 

Updated 17th May 2013

  

LATEST NEWS

All 4 new top end models now available and initial technical glitches resolved with new modifications

AXT 2000 HP & AXT 2200HP Quiet Shredders now discontinued and unavailable

Beckham and Ronaldo get shredding lessons from Fred at the Chelsea Flower Show

    

 

 

The 22D and 25D use the same cog mechanism as my old favourite, the AXT2200HP, but now have built in collection boxes.

The AXT23TC and AXT25TC models use a new turbine cutting mechanism that shreds hard and soft material. I am testing one now.

Stocks of the old AXT2000HP, and  AXT2200HP are gone .  If you see one it is going to be a graded return and best avoided.

Mail me for the latest news or if you need help or are confused (about shredders) or want my ongoing test results on the new TC model - pictured above

FAQ's

 Bosch shredders come with a 2 year warranty and excellent service backup.

23TC or 25TC models use the same size turbine cutting blade, the 25 has 300w of extra power

I anticipate turbines will last 4-5 years, no problems reported so far.

Had 4 reports of circuit board failure causing TC models to stick in reverse . problem limited to one small batch

Garden shredders are designed for WOODY plant material.

Please don't mail me to ask about shredding food waste,  nappies, cardboard or straw.

ALL domestic shredders have a small top opening that is restricted by EU safety law

UK enquiries only please - there is only me in this shed!

(and I like to get out now and again!)

Here is a choice of links to get the best deals.

Option 1 - all models - (except AXT 22D - it is poor value compared to the AXT25D  )

  

                                                                  ALL NEW MODELS HAVE BUILT IN BOXES

FOR RAPID 2000,  RAPID 2200,  &AXT23TC   USE LINKS BELOW- FOR BEST PRICE

For AXT23TC  & AXT 25D CHECK ALL MY  LINKS  - FOR BEST PRICE

Special deal  (17.5.13)

AXT25 TC  £369.99 inc free delivery

check prices and availability of all Bosch shredders at garden4less

WANT THE CHEAPER MODEL FOR SMALLER JOBS?

USE LINK BELOW AND GET A FREE SPARE BLADE

 Buy Bosch AXT2200 Rapid with a spare blade

 

A SKIP LIKE THIS COSTS £190 AND YOU CANT SELL IT ON EBAY AFTER USING IT!

A SHREDDER IS A BETTER DEAL AND WILL PRODUCE FREE MULCH TOO.

I CHECK REGULARLY TO FIND YOU THE BEST DEALS,  THE BEST SUPPLIERS

AND UPGRADED STOCK WITH THE LATEST IMPROVEMENTS

PLEASE USE MY LINKS TO SUPPORT MY WORK AND SAVE YOU MONEY

    (The rapid 2000 is currently £159.99 at B&Q  )

You can buy its even better, big brother for much  less using my link below

THE AXT2200 RAPID IS THE MOST POPULAR BUDGET SHREDDER AND YOU CANT GO FAR WRONG WITH IT

However as it works like a food processor I recommend having a spare blade as it will blunt at some stage.

spare blades currently cost £20 and take 5 minutes to change

       

                Buy Bosch AXT2200 Rapid with a spare blade

 click for Bosch shredder collection bag

 

GARDEN SHREDDERS TESTED

 

I have tested dozens of shredders over the last 10 years, for domestic use I like Bosch shredders and am happy to share my findings with my readers.

The reason I prefer Bosch shredders is that they innovate rather than copy and supply all spare parts & 2 year warranty

I test and compare the best with the rest!

Bosch verses Flymo -no contest

 Click here for my page of Reader Comments

 

Bosch have made 4 different types of garden shredder, ( 1 Rapid and 3 Quiet types)

There are 6 models currently in production (of 3 types!)

The Rapid type is simple but noisy and better for softer material

The  quiet types (not silent) self feed and crush woody material

The new TC models crush and cut both woody and green material, and are also quiet

Unfortunately the model numbers are very similar and confusing   (many retailers don't have a clue )

Which one is best? Fred-in-the-shed explains

 

Bosch rapid shredder

copied badly by numerous companies

 

My old 2000 - 10 years ago

 

Bosch  AXT 180 , AXT 200, AXT2000, AXT2200 Rapid  Shredders

These use the spinning blade -(like a heavy duty food processor)

 Not so long ago shredders were very expensive and the cheapest ones were appalling to use due to noise and jamming up or breaking. As shredders have become more popular the economies of scale of mass production has reduced the prices further.

Some of the cheap shredders are still total rubbish and should be avoided. There are a few cheap, but good ones available around the £150 mark.

The Bosch AXT RAPID impact shredders were introduced in 2004 and were designed to take soft foliage as well as woody branches up to  38mm. These machines have double (reversible) blades unlike the single "razor blade type" of many cheap shredders.

One unique and innovative feature of the AXT rapid shredders is the wide paddle that is used to push material into the top of the machine. Other shredders give you a metal rod or stick which is not as good.

A replacement blade that fits all the Bosch rapid shredders costs about £15 and takes me 5 minutes to change.

Some of my readers reported rapid blade wear in some machines bought form Argos and in response Bosch have developed a new improved blade made in Switzerland. (SEPT 06).

I strongly recommend that if you are buying a Bosch rapid shredder or replacement blade that it is the new Swiss made one.

 

 

Bosch  AXT 1600 HP , AXT 2000 HP and AXT 2200HP Quiet Shredders

(all discontinued)

This is the older range of Bosch shredders that are also branded ATCO since Bosch owned the  ATCO brand.

Like most equipment you get what you pay for and these Quiet shredders are more expensive as they are well engineered and contain more components than simple spinning blade shredders.

These were German made machines and in normal use will last years. However eventually if you do a lot of shredding even this machine will need new parts, (most probably the cog, or screw, bearings or plastic roller)

Unlike spinning blade type shredders the Bosch AXT1600HP and AXT2000 HP are unique as they use a spiral screw to crush the branches and pull them in. A replacement spiral screw costs about £80 and is quite a job to replace. Although these machines are good quality they are most prone to problems so I prefer to recommend other machines and would advised Bosch to discontinue them.( which they did!)

The Bosch AXT2200HP uses cogs to crush the branches which although more robust than a spiral screw are still expensive to replace compared to spinning blade. The crushing cog shredders are the toughest and I have had the least complaints about them. Sadly Bosch discontinued this one too.

Many complaints about shredder failure are due to misuse, (I would say about 50%). The rest are mostly about worn spirals and this is why I don't recommend buying a Bosch AXT2000HP or 1600HP, which are now very old and on their way to landfill heaven.

 

 

Garden Shredders Explained

Different blade types -  pros and cons

   

Reversible double edged blade to fit all Bosch Rapid Shredders

One size fits all!

 click for Bosch rapid shredder blade

 

This is a simple blade as found on Bosch Rapid or cutting type shredders. . This Bosch one is reversible and has 2 cutting edges on each blade. Many cheap shredders  have only 1  blade with two cutting edges- that's one reason they are cr#p.

 

To replace a blade on a Bosch rapid shredder is easy.

Open the top and the Allen key required is sitting there in its little slot!

Avoid soil in your shredder to prolong blade life.

Also wire, stones and knotty wood.!

 

                   

The AXT2200HP crushing cog type blade and bar

Now on AXT 22D and AXT25D

This is the more complicated cog and drum mechanism of the crushing type shredders. These are reliable and well tested, they cannot be sharpened but rarely need replacing as the softer plate is designed to take most of the strain and wear.

On the old aXT2200HP the cog can be easily accessed by removing 4 hex bolts on the front of the shredder.

 

 

 

Simple razor blade type shredder blade as found on cheap "non Bosch" impact shredders

As you can imagine these blades literally "take a lot of stick" and go blunt very quickly. Also some manufacturers have increased motor power without upgrading the blades, so they fail even quicker! On top of this most "pile em up - sell em cheap" retailers will not sell blades, or know where to get them.

 

The helix or spiral cutter from the discontinued AXT1600HP and AXT2000HP machines.

These spiral cutters make the machine extremely quiet and self feeding. However the edges can be damaged by stones and wire so take care what you put into this type of shredder. As a result I recommend buying a rapid shredder or the new models with cog or turbine cutters. If you have a Bosch AXT1600HP or AXT2000HP and it is not shredding properly, (stringy shreddings), then the helix is probably damaged.

Replacing a helix will cost around £95 in parts and take 90 minutes to do.

Parts available from  healystool.co.uk

(You will also need a circlip plier to remove it )

 

Which Shredder for Your needs?

(you can mail me for a free, personal recommendation)

The paddle will help you push in stringy material but the shredder is better at long thin branches.

Be very careful not to get any soil in your shredder!

Due to the high speed even a small amount of soil can blunt a blade in seconds

 

 

 

The spinning blade shredders work like a food processor and can handle soft stems and green foliage as well as long thin woody stems.

This is fine until your blades become blunt,  then the cutting efficiency is reduced and blockages occur and the "shreddings" become long thin and stringy..

The blades can be sharpened but only a couple of times. Typically replacement blades cost between £10 and £25 a set.

Wet green material often blunts blades very quickly, also dead hard wood. Try to shred material whilst still soft and shortly after pruning.

Buy Bosch AXT2200 Rapid with a spare blade

 

 

The crushing cog type shredders are fantastic at pulling in big woody stems up to 38mm wide as long as you trim the bottom side shoots off first.

However , crushing cog type shredders are not so good at handling soft stems and green foliage, as some may pass through uncut. Which is not really a problem as it will rot down quickly anyway.

The shredder shown above is the AL-KO SP5000 which is similar to the Bosch AXT2200HP but more expensive.

If you would rather buy an AL-KO shredder mail me for a competitive price - please include model number and your location.

Another similar shredder is the Wolf SDL 2500. This is also a Chinese copy of the Bosch AXT2200HP but has a smaller crushing cog and did not perform as well in my tests.

I tested the Flymo and although it worked ok it was not as good as the Bosch AXT2200HP , but it is cheaper and the feature of folding into the inbuilt collection box is a clever space saving idea.

 

 

 

AVAILABLE NOW - FOR BOSCH  RAPID SHREDDERS

 IMPROVED SWISS MADE LASER CUT BLADE

Upgrade your Bosch Rapid Shredder with the new laser cut blade made in Switzerland

lasts up to 70% longer

 click for Bosch rapid shredder blade

  

I also seriously recommend the special collection bag or small tubrug as these new rapid shredders really spit out the waste and  make a mess of your garden.

click for Bosch shredder collection bag

Also spray your blades, before and after use with the lubricant below to deter rust. It is UK made and also smells of lavender!

Ideal for all garden tools and machinery, bikes, door hinges etc etc

   

I use the Lux Optical safety glasses which are superb value for money

 

My favourite silent shredder was the Bosch AXT 2200 HP which uses a cog mechanism and is the most robust and heavy duty of the Bosch shredders.

 In 2009 this model was replaced by new versions known as the AXT22 D and AXT25D that have built in collection boxes.

  There are still some retailers clearing the old  models but they are likely to be graded, repaired stock.

Also if you see a Bosch shredder for sale at prices significantly lower than you see on fredshed it is highly likely that they will be graded (second hand) machines, or old stock lacking any recent technical upgrades. There may be some good ones about and if you find one good luck to you.

Whilst some products are ok when graded I don't think shredders are one of them due to the high stresses placed on the components.

Shredder repair tips

I have taken apart and repaired a number of shredders.

Parts are available for all Bosch shredders, including the obsolete ones.

For parts Try healystool.co.uk  , I don't supply shredder parts.

If you bought a shredder from ebay or some discount suppler  and have problems then please contact them, not me.

First point of call for all repairs/ technical questions is Bosch.

.For Bosch repairs call 0844 736 0109, they do a collect and inspect service, for approx £35

give you a quote and will dispose of it if it is not viable to repair

I am sorry I can no longer answer queries on repairing obsolete machines.

I also don't have wiring diagrams for any shredder.

 

 
 

 The Honest Truth -

Do I know of any problems with Bosch Shredder?

Yes - but mostly small ones -

The silent shredders have been in production for many years and remain unchanged. The problems that have occurred are largely down to users trying to put oversize branches, wire, soil or stones in the machines. Most problems occur with the AXT2000HP. The AXT2200HP is virtually "bullet proof". The new AXT23TC, 25TC, 22D, and 25D suffered from some initial technical faults that I helped Bosch identify and resolve. They are still not perfect but very good and small improvements will probably follow.

The cheaper AXT rapid shredders were introduced in 2004 and are solid and robust. I have abused one constantly in my testing and as long as the blades are kept sharp it performs very well. Initially some were shipped with factory induced faults, and became blunt very quickly. A new Swiss made blade is now available that Bosch claim lasts up to 70% longer.

The new models with built in boxes had a few issues at first too. Mainly the plate adjuster knob which was completely redesigned and is now black, not green, on updated models. I have also heard of 6 AXT25D models that have become stuck in reverse and had to have new circuit boards fitted under warranty. This, I am told by Bosch is down to one batch of circuit boards only.

The Bosch websites do contain a lot of information but are hard to navigate.

You can also ring the Bosch Garden customer care line on

0844 736 0108

Bosch Service Centre Robert Bosch Ltd.
P.O. Box 98
Broadwater Park
Denham, Middlesex
UB9 5HJ

 

 

 

Any machine in mass production will occasionally suffer from manufacturing errors. In my experience these are very few in the case of Bosch shredders and more importantly I don't know of any design errors.

My research has discovered the following problems..

AXT200 rapid - a batch sold in Argos had blades that were not tempered properly and were too soft - Bosch replaced them for my readers and gave advice on forum webpage. Some readers have complained of blades losing sharpness after very short periods of use.

NEW SWISS LASER CUT BLADES NOW AVAILABLE

AXT200 rapid - faulty switch from new-manufacturing error

batch of blades not hardened properly - now obsolete

AXT 180 - reader broke the plastic top cover- this was caused by trying to pull through too large a branch with a hard knot - solution - cut of knots and tough protrusions before feeding onto shredder.

Both the above machines now replaced by new models made in Swizterland

AXT 1600 HP Quiet Shredder-  reader damaged blade with wire that was attached to branch - my advice - take care when feeding branches  - also do not eat glass, nails carpets and other items that may damage your stomach.

AXT2000HP Quiet shredder - clogging caused by bucket under shredder filling up and not allowing "shreddings" through. solution - empty bucket.

damage to spiral blade -probably wire or stones. (most common problem)

damage to plastic cover - caused by thick knotted branch

faulty switch mechanism

AXT2200HP - breakage of £16 plate that presses on cog - unknown cause, most likely oversize and knotty wood. Some later models had motor fans poorly fixed, No other known  faults reported.

 

What comes out of your Bosch Shredder?

Chippings from Bosch AXT D Cog crushing  models

These are the "chunkings" from a Buddliea that went through my test model AXT2200HP shredder. The spiral cutting AXT1600HP and AXT2000HP produce similar large size chunkings.

You will notice that the pieces are quite large and some soft green leaves got through relatively unscathed.

If you shred woody material these large "chunkings" make excellent weed suppressing mulch that will take ages to rot down. If you want small chippings to compost quickly then best get another type of shredder.

My personal opinion is that it is more environmentally friendly to let soft material rot naturally in a well made compost heap- if you have the space. Just shred the woody stuff and keep anything over 40cm thick for firewood.

 

Chippings from Bosch AXT TC turbine cut models

These are the mixed size shreddings of various plants  that went through my test model AXT23 TC  shredder.

I have placed a 50p piece in the middle so you have an idea of scale. The size of material produced will vary with what you put in but the main difference is that green material will be more cut up and smaller than if it had been through one of the D models.

 

 

 

 

Chunkings from Quiet Shredders ( D models)

 

Chippings from AXT TC models

 

Chippings from Bosch AXT rapid , spinning blade ( impact,)   models

If you want smaller chippings or you want to shred softer green material the RAPID shredders are for you.

My top tip is to shred material shortly after pruning and try not to stuff too much in at once.

Impact shredders will give stringy "shreddings" if you put too many twigs down together, or the blades get blunt.  If you want fine, even shreddings, then single long stems are the best provider of this.

If you have a small garden or want a lightweight shredder the rapid version is best.

 Buy Bosch AXT2200 Rapid with a spare blade

 

 

Finer chippings  from Rapid Shredders

 

 

 Click here for my page of Reader Comments

 

IF YOU FOUND THIS PAGE USEFUL PLEASE CONSIDER USING MY LINKS WHEN MAKING YOUR PURCHASE AS THIS HELPS TO PAY FOR THE COST OF RUNNING MY SITE.

ALSO I HAVE CAREFULLY SELECTED THE BEST SUPPLIERS SO YOU WON'T GET FOBBED OFF WITH AN OLD MODEL OR GRADED PRODUCT.

THANKS

FRED-IN-THE-SHED

click here for my new page on cordless mowers

Click link below to see my new page on

Solar Garden Lights

 

Other Makes of garden shredders I have tested

 

 

        

 

The JCB shredder was pants, the Makita was difficult to move and overpriced.

The old Bosch was best but new models are even better!

The Draper shredder was made well but performance was comparatively poor.

 

AL-KO SP5000

similar to Bosch AXT2200HP

Shredding Leaves in a Garden Shredder      

(JUST DON'T DO IT) 

Ok if on branches- not if loose on ground!

Many people ask which shredder is best for shredding fallen leaves and the answer is a big one with a large hopper.

However, shovelling in piles of leaves is one of the best ways to kill any shredder as so often stones and other debris sneak in and damage the blades or  worse.

Also the type of shredders that can cope with leaves are usually petrol driven, heavy and expensive. To have a wide opening and meet safety regulations means the distance from top to blade must be longer than the longest arm, hence these machine are massive the top is often out of shovel reach anyway.

I personally think that shredding leaves is a waste of time and a better way of managing them is to let them rot down in a dedicated heap, container , or in bio-degradable jute sacks. Fallen leaves are one of natures best composts and provide the fertility for the forest floor and trees.

Leaves can take a couple of years to rot properly but then can be spread out to form a fantastic fertile, and weed suppressing carpet.

Well rotted leaf mulch smells nice and is clean to handle.

How to Speed up Composting of shredded material

If you want to speed up the rate your shredded material composts then I recommend a handful of Garotta every now and again.

Add some water at the same time as compost will not break down if it is too dry. Cover the heap or container to keep the heat and moisture in.

I have used this product for over 20 yeas now and have found it to be very effective.

Arguably peeing on your compost heap will achieve the same effect but I think it is a bit smelly and not as convenient, especially for the ladies.

 

 

 

T

I have tested the following shredders

AL-KO SP5000 Silent shredder, AL-KO Powerslider2500R shredder, Atco 1800 Quiet shredder, Bosch AXT 180 Rapid Shredder, Bosch AXT200 Rapid Shredder, Bosch AXT2000 HP Silent Shredder, Black & Decker GA 1600e shredder, Draper 1800w Shredder, JCB GSB 1800 Shredder, Makita DSH201 Shredder, Powerdevil shredder.Wolf SDL2500.

my readers have provided feedback on the

Ryobi RGS 1500 Shredder, MTD 115E shredder, Viking GE35L shredder, VikingGE103 shredder.Viking GE 250. B&Q performance 2100w Quiet shredder

 

Heavy Duty Garden Shredders

The image below shows the 9 blades found on Makita Garden shredders. There are 2 models, one electric and one petrol - both cut up to 50mm and are built to last.

price guide £600

but still not as easy to use as the AXT25D

or as effective as the AXT25TC

 

Tips on using shredders

Always have secateurs and loppers on  hand!

BEST LOPPERS TO  PREPARE BRANCHES FOR SHREDDING

A bit of preparation is essential for fast, easy shredding.

Firstly have loppers and secateurs at hand to trim off side branches and knotty wood. This will not only make shredding faster and easier but will help to prevent unnecessary strain on your shredder.

The Fiskars Powegear  Anvil loppers are very robust and reliable loppers and have the added advantage of a gear mechanism to give more cutting power. The slight downside is that you have to open them wider than standard loppers. They are ideal for cutting branches to feed into shredders.

Made in Finland the simple gear mechanism  makes cutting easier on thick stems.. If there were trees on the moon these would be the loppers used by NASA! They cut branches up to 45mm (which is also the maximum diameter for a domestic garden shredder)

  They are made of a new lightweight, but super strong material called "fibrecomp" .

If you want telescopic loppers my recommended ones are from Wolf Garten. I have owned and tested dozens of loppers in the last 15 years and these are my overall favourites as they give me extra reach,  a great cut, and are superb quality. The Wolf Telescopic loppers are made in Germany and like all the best loppers have oval section handles for ultimate strength.

What sets them apart from cheaper telescopic loppers is the durable and rapid sliding handle adjusters. I have owned this pair for 10 years and given them a lots of use - and only lightly sharpened the blade a couple of times. They cost £40 and if you cant afford that go for the Bulldog made Alan Titchmarsh loppers. They have a ratchet mechanism too so require less strength to use

My recommended secateurs for shredding are these strong and cheap Aluminium ratchet secateurs from Bulldog Tools and Alan Titchmarcsh.

They will cut through large branches easily and  reduce your risk of RSI.

Please use the links below to buy at a great price and support this page.

 

use link below to price compare Wolf Loppers with another Fredshed partner

 buy Fred's favourite telescopic loppers

 

 

Fred's Favorite Loppers

My loppers are 10 yeas old and still cut perfectly

 buy Fred's favourite telescopic loppers

 The Wolf Loppers are approx £39 in delivery

please use the link below

They are being replaced with a new more expensive model so buy soon while stocks last.

buy Fred's favourite telescopic loppers

Available with  Anvil or Bypass type blade

Also used by Vern in his Technicolor dreamcoat!

 

 

 

Essential Safety Equipment when using shredders

Gloves, goggles and even ear protection should be used when shredding.. Make sure your goggles are clean and your gloves fit properly.

If you have long hair tie -it back  You could end up with a very bad haircut or unusual mulch!

Make sure you clean and sharpen blades on impact shredders regularly.

Empty the bucket that collects the "shreddings" frequently and don't allow material to back up into the lower shute.

Brush or vacuum the motor vents occasionally to prevent overheating and cutouts.

Be a real shredding fanatic and fit an outside power socket!

 

 

 

Long stems shred easily- do one at a time to prevent clogging

 

 

Hope you liked my page?

Help me, and yourself by buying some safety gogs using the links above

 

Spare Parts for Bosch Shredders another garden machinery

By law manufacturers electrical equipment must supply spare parts for 10 years.

Many companies who source their products from China do not,  and cannot meet this requirement. This includes some household names.

Bosch  keep this promise and provide operating manuals and  parts diagrams for all models and a dealer locator on their website .

Click here for all Bosch Shredder parts lists

I'm not saying the parts will be cheap or even that a repair to your product is viable, ( skilled labour is expensive) but all parts are available.

 

                     Call 0844 736 0109 for repairs and technical advice on your Bosch shredder

Want my personal tip for the best shredder for your garden?
 

e-mail me at


fred@fredshed.com 

I always reply! (UK only please)

If you found my advice helpful you can support my work by returning to this page and using my links when purchasing your secateurs. Also any products bought from Amazon using the links below will produce a small commission that helps cover my hosting costs. thanks, Fred

         

 

If you found my site helpful and would like to make a small donation please use the link below. Thank you. Fred

 

 

click on the shed to return to the homepage

 

 other pages

Builders bits    cordless chainsaws   Decorating Tools   Digging Tools      forks & Spades        

DIY products       garden shredders     lawn tools    new products     mowers

   cordless hedgetrimmers    Powered garden equipment   Robot Mowers 

     pruning tools        Weekly tips page   Workshop tools

                  Torches

 

            site plan

See My New Page - Fred's Top 10 Practical Gifts

SEE MY NEW PAGE ON KITCHEN TOOLS & GADGETS

 

© Fred Walden 2013