Vacuum Cleaners Tested and Reviewed

                             

Updated 5th December 2008

I have tested the following  machines.

 

Black and Decker Dustbusters

including 7.2v Cyclonic and 14.4v Dustbuster Pivot

Gtech floor sweeper

DYSON DCO4, DC07

Kirby G4 and G5

Makita 12v cordless vacuum

Hoover Freejet cordless vacuum

Exakt Dust Extraction vacuum for Powertools

DeWalt 18v Cordless Vacuum cleaner

Earlex Combi Powervac

  COMING SOON
AMAZING KARCHER WV50 PLUS WINDOW VACUUM

 

Black and Decker Pivoting Nose Cordless Vacuum Cleaners

12v, 14.4v and 18v (USA only)

 

I have been testing the dustbusters over the last 7 years and seen continual improvements in battery power and most importantly filter design.

Many cheaper vacuum cleaners quickly lose performance as dust clogs the filter. The new Pivot nose Dustbusters have cyclonic filters with 2 cones that can be shaken without opening the machine, therefore loosening the dust and unclogging the filter. Also these filters can now be reused and washed under a tap.

Replacement filters are about $10 and it is worth having a clean spare handy if you use it a lot as washed filters need to be dried before use.

I tested the 14.4v version in the UK but USA consumers get a more powerful 18v version which has the same design and filters and is highly rated by reviewers on Amazon and popular mechanics

Dyson DC16 Handheld

This is the "big daddy" of the cordless vacuum cleaners as it has the most power at 21volts and a Lithium ion battery that recharges in 3 hours.

Whilst I have no doubt that it has the best and most consistent suction it is large, and the battery duration is very short at less than 5 minutes. This is because a big motor (and hence a big battery) is needed to power the dual cyclone that is unique to Dyson.

A breakthrough in technology with looks to match. This hand vac is ideal for small clean-ups and use in caravans, boats etc but is not designed as a substitute for your main vacuum cleaner.

 

Dyson DC16 handheld  (21v)

 

 

 

In the UK the 14.4 volt Black & Decker Dustbuster is the latest and most powerful  model of this long running range of cordless vacuums.

I have tested the 12v and 14.4v version over the last year and been very impressed with the power and capacity.

Whilst I would say that this is the best cordless vacuum I have ever tested it is not perfect and does have a few minor annoying features that may prevent it from winning a coveted Golden Shed Award.

The extending nose can be hard to push back or just goes back when you don't want it too. I would advise B&D to improve the mouldings.

Likewise the lid to the dustbox sometimes has not locked in and the dust fallen out.

The storage for the little brush is pants and now I have lost it.

Apart from these foibles it is a superb machine and indispensable in my home and workshop.

 

 

 

 

New Power take off Vacuum cleaners for saws and sanders

 If you use a power tool that creates dust like this laminate cutting saw or a sander then a vacuum cleaner that includes a power take off socket will make the job much easier. It does this  by saving you time not having to switch both of them on and off. When you switch on the saw or sander the vac switches on too!

When you switch off your saw or sander the vac runs for a few more seconds to collect all the dust and then automatically turns off too!

As the vac has its own extra power socket   you can use it like an extension lead as well, even if you don't need the vac facility. This type of vacuum is usually an expensive product for professional users but this British made vacuum costs around £80 and will also suck up liquids too!

On top of this is can also be used as a blower and I even used it outside to suck up small leaves and debris from my lawn and decking.

 

The British made Earlex Combi Powervac is the perfect workshop vacuum as it has a power take off socket and does wet and dry!

  see details on power take off vacuum cleaner

 

 

 

Buy this power take off vacuum for £69 inc delivery

UK only!

 

 

 

Gtech SWO2 Floor Sweeper

Sometimes the simplest machines are the best and this little battery powered floor sweeper fits that description.

The Gtech SW02 is so light and efficient, you can wizz round the room in seconds without the noise and effort of plugging in a heavy vacuum cleaner.

I was amazed how much it picks up and it is so easy to empty thanks to its nifty dirtbox that just slides out.

This machine can be used with one hand and is perfect for all sorts of people including wheelchair users like me!

 

 

 

No bags, no cords, no filters- just picks up dirt the easy way -by brushing

Surprisingly this little sweeper is ideal for DIY mess like plaster and concrete dust (small pieces). This because is does not have filters to block and just sweeps and collects.

 

DysonVacuum cleaners

Long term tests

I have owned  many Dyson vacuum cleaners and overall am pleased with the performance and love the fact I don't have to buy bags.

My original DC01 is probably dead by now but served me well and represented a major breakthrough in domestic cleaner technology and a boost for UK inventors.

My long serving DC04 did develop a minor switch fault and I was a bit annoyed that Dyson would not provide diagrams or tell me how to take the machine apart to fix a simple problem. Dysons are designed to resist screwdrivers and only be opened by Dyson technicians. for safety reasons) 

However Dyson do have a great website and customer service and offer long warranties now with all new machines.

 

Tony loved his Dyson but Chris got Jealous and it had to go

The Dyson DC04 was a good machine but let down by minor problems with the on/off switch

The DC07 is a similar machines with no known problems (to me anyway)

Reasons for poor performance of Dyson Vacuums

From my own experience and from what repairers and shops have told me the main reason Dyson vacuum cleaners may lose suction and fail to perform is due to blocked filters or dust bars being wrapped up in pet hair or carpet fibres.

A vacuum cleaner needs to move air and dirt and breath. If the brush bar cannot move it cant beat the carpet and push the dust particles towards the filters and collection box.

Most Dysons have 2 filters, one before the motor to trap fine dust and one after the motor to make sure the air it pushes out is a clean as possible. (Pre and post motor filters)

 

This poor Dyson DC07 was thrown away as the owner said it was rubbish and didn't suck anymore. If she had removed most of her cat from the brush bar it would have worked a treat.

 

I own 2 Dyson DC07 vacuums, one I bought and one I repaired in 10 minutes after it was thrown away as it was dirty.

Dyson now give long warranties and pay more attention to quality control ( as mentioned in their adverts)

My slight criticism of older  Dysons means I am no longer on their Christmas card list. Despite this I still recommend their products as I truly believe they are good.

My current Dyson is a DCO7   (X2)  and is even better as it has a HEPA filter and easy empty mechanism to prevent dust getting in your face when emptying.

My favorite Dyson is the DC07  as it is robust and effective and easy to sue. It has 2 filters, one under the bin (post motor) which cleans the exhausted air and the main "pre motor"  filter which is on the side and is made from washable foam. Keep this filter clean and your Dyson DC07 will suck like a - sucking thing. If you have had a good or bad experience with Dyson vacuum cleaners please let me know at  fred@fredshed.com

 

 FOR USA READERS

If you own a Dyson DC07 I recommend having a spare foam filter and wash and change them over  monthly. to maintain 100% efficiency.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Other models of Dyson

The range has been expanded to include handhelds, lightweights, and cylinder models to cater for every floor type, household or lifestyle.

Although I am not able to test and review every model I am confident in the underlying patented technology of the dual cyclone that makes Dyson vacuums superior in suction and performance to most other makes.

If you have had a bad experience with any particular model please let me know so I can let other readers know.

In March 2008 Dyson released the new DC25 which is a lightweight upright. If anybody has one I would love to hear your opinion on it. Is it worth £289?

 

 

The Best Vacuum Cleaner - My 15 year old Kirby?

This is my Kirby G3 vacuum cleaner. It is about 15 years old and still going strong. New Kirby vacuum cleaners are over £1000 and mostly sold at shows or during home visits.  My advice is to buy a nearly new or well serviced one from e-bay as the Kirby sales technique is very American and likely to persuade you to part with "big bucks" when all you wanted was a reasonably priced quality machine

On the plus side, the Kirby has phenomenal performance and the carpet cleaning attachment has made my carpets last years longer.

The best feature of Kirby vacuum cleaners is the durability. Kirbys are built like tanks and last forever. Parts are not cheap but always available. Over time the Kirby begins to pay back the initial investment and I am quite fond of my "old K"

 

A few more of my thoughts on Kirby vacuum cleaners.

Fitting the different attachments is a real pain, and requires lots of practice.

The head/dog massaging attachment is ridiculous and could seriously endanger your health and scare your dog.

The bags are expensive, if Kirby made a cyclonic - no- bag version it would truly be the best vacuum cleaner around. However they would lose revenue on bags so I am not expecting one soon

 

 

 

Vacuum Cleaners tested

Kirby G3 Verses Dyson DC04

As I have owned both these machines for many years I decided to undertake a simple test.

Starting with empty/clean dustbags/collecting bowls,  I vacuumed my carpet with the Kirby and then the Dyson, then repeated the experiment the other way around.

To my amazement I discovered that the Dyson picked up dirt that the Kirby had left behind!

As a  vacuum cleaner the Kirby can be beaten but it is a very good carpet cleaner too and will outlast most machines.

The Dyson is a great vacuum cleaner lasts reasonably well if cared for. However some models look very flimsy and  I would like to see James Dyson make a real quality one, built to last like the Kirby.

 

 

 

Numatic Henry - A cheap solution to Commercial cleaning

I know quite a few professional cleaners who use the Henry for vacuuming hallways and public areas in large residential complexes.

The Henry has been around years and has a reputation for being tough and effective. There are 2 models, the newest does wet and dry and amazingly both are still made in Britain.

I dont think I have heard one complaint about a Henry and as this product has been around years the spares are easy to get too.

the bags are also cheap at about 50p each.

 

 

 

   
   

DeWalt Cordless Vacuum

Professional cleanup vacuum for builders and tradesmen

DeWalt are a very innovative company who respond quickly to customers needs and provide tools we want.

If you buy a DeWalt cordless drill you can also find a huge range of other powertools to go with it. The 18v range is most favoured with tradesmen and builders and is widely available. 3 of the Fredshed test team of tradesmen use these tools and swear by them.

This is me at Interbuild trying the excellent DeWalt DC515N-XJ 18v cordless vacuum which EVERY BUILDER SHOULD OWN! - you filthy devils!

 

 

click for more details on the DeWalt 18v cordless vacuum

   

Karcher Steam Cleaners

This is my Karcher SC952 hand held domestic steam cleaner. ( A kettle with a nozzle and safety features)

I use this little machine to clean my fridge, dirty windows, carpets and grubby shower floor (as shown).

This little machine has its limitations * but is a handy little tool that will pay for itself in time by savings on cleaning products. I think a small machine like this is best suited to fabrics and light cleaning, *It will not touch thick grease or lime scale

For that you need Cilit Bang! (really).

 

 

 

coming soon ! the amazing Karcher cordless window cleaning vacuum.

click on the shed to return to the homepage

 

 

 Weekly tips page       deals        Powered equipment       site plan